Back to Top
JUDGING CRITERIA  
  1. 1. Vision and Teamwork (16 marks)
    1.   1.1 Vision on quality
    2.   1.2 Overview of project requirements
    3.   1.3 Teamwork and project management
    4.   1.4 Financial and contract management
    5.   1.5 Total quality and risk management
    6.   1.6 Quality improvement
    7.   1.7 Social and Cultural harmony with neighboring community
  1. 2. Design and Innovation (20 marks)
    1. 2.1 Design and materials consideration for long-term upkeep of building
    2. 2.2 Site planning, neighborhood and cityscape considerations
    3. 2.3 Distinctive feature beyond statutory requirements and general practices
    4. 2.4 Design innovations, aesthetic and distinction
    5. 2.5 Engineering design for quality, build ability and durability
    6. 2.6 Solutions for challenges
  1. 3. Construction (16 marks)
    1. 3.1 Construction processes, technique, building technologies, choice of materials and quality workmanship
    2. 3.2 Project management and organization, and integration
    3. 3.3 Safety, Health, Environment and Quality (during the construction stage)
  1. 4. Project Cost & Budget (16 marks)
    1. 4.1 Cost and benefit in Structural design/ E&M design/ Facility Management/ Architectural design/ Construction
    2. 4.2 Intangible benefits, e.g. image, brand etc.
    3. 4.3 Tangible benefits, e.g. financial, physical etc.
    4. 4.4 Operation, maintenance and repair costs
    5. 4.5 Cost for sustainability, e.g. life cycle etc.
    6. 4.6 Procurement strategy, arrangement and documentation
  1. 5. Environmental Considerations (16 marks)
    1. 5.1 Environmental impact and sustainability
    2. 5.2 Energy efficiency and life-cycle
    3. 5.3 Waste management and recycling
    4. 5.4 Construction and occupational health and safety management and training
    5. 5.5 Safety features cater for maintenance and service (specifically on the societal impact of the whole project)
    6. 5.6 Greening and carbon emission reduction
  1. 6. Post-Occupancy Considerations (16 marks)
    1. 6.1 Occupiers’ response and customer satisfaction
    2. 6.2 Corporate governance and social responsibility
    3. 6.3 Serviceability and performance outcome and community contribution
    4. 6.4 Operation and maintenance features and cost effectiveness
    5. 6.5 Functionality, flexibility and adaptation for changes

* Zero point will be given if no information is provided under the relevant section.